Why Unlimited PTO is a Scam

In a job market defined by fierce competition for talent, companies are aggressively rolling out perks to attract and retain the best employees. Among the most alluring and misleading of these benefits is “unlimited” paid time off (PTO). 

Marketed as a sign of a progressive, trust-based culture, the promise of ultimate flexibility sounds like a dream. But while less than 10% of companies offer this policy, its reality rarely lives up to the hype. It seems too good to be true because it usually is. 

The truth is that unlimited PTO often creates a culture of anxiety, leads employees to take less time off, and serves as a clever financial ploy for the company. The following analysis reveals why this policy is one of the most deceptive perks in the modern workplace. 

What Are Unlimited Vacation Days? 

Unlimited vacation days are policies allowing employees to request paid time off without a predetermined allotment. In practice, however, many employees hesitate to use their full flexibility due to concerns about workload and perceptions of commitment. 

The reality is that unlimited vacation days are often more complicated to use effectively. 

“Unlimited PTO is a scam to avoid legal obligations around paying you banked time if you leave or are terminated.” — Reddit User 

Unlimited vacation days are not accrual-based. This means that your PTO will have zero value when you leave the company. Instead, when PTO is quantified, you can actually earn a payout when you move on to your next endeavor if you do not use all your paid leave. 

And, most companies offering unlimited leave have complicated rules about when and how you can take your time off. 

Why Unlimited PTO Fails in Practice

Nobody Knows How Much Is “Too Much”

On paper, an employee with unlimited PTO could take weeks and weeks off. In reality, the lack of explicit guidelines creates a dangerous ambiguity. Workers struggle to answer “how much PTO is too much?”  

No one wants to be the person perceived as abusing the policy. Especially for new hires or those in competitive environments, there’s an unspoken tension: if you take more vacation than your peers or than your boss, will you be seen as less dedicated?  

This ambiguity often leads employees to take less time off than they would under a traditional plan.  

By the end of the year, many realize they skipped vacations they needed, and unlike a normal PTO plan, there’s no carryover or payout. Those vacation days are simply lost. 

The numbers support this. A survey found that workers at companies with unlimited PTO only take around 10 days off per year on average. Whereas the typical American employee, most having fixed allotments, takes about 15 days off annually. This shows how “limitless” vacations often result in people vacationing less.  

Why does this happen?  The root cause is uncertainty and anxiety. With no set entitlement, employees are left to interpret what’s acceptable. Psychologically, many default to taking fewer days to avoid looking like a slacker.  

Unlimited PTO Helps Companies, Not Employees

Beyond the cultural challenges, unlimited PTO serves a significant financial purpose for the company, often at the expense of the employee.  

Under traditional PTO policies, unused vacation days are a financial liability on the company’s balance sheet. These are hours the company owes you, as paid time off or payout, once earned. 

If you leave the company with unused vacation, many employers have to compensate you for that time. In fact, in some states, unused vacation must be paid out by law, because it’s considered earned wages. 

Switching to an unlimited PTO policy wipes that leave liability off the books. Suddenly, there is no accrued vacation time, and nothing to pay out or carry as a debt owed to employees. 

As a Business Insider report bluntly put it, unlimited PTO is a “well-known financial accounting hack” for employers. It makes the company instantly more valuable on paper because a chunk of potential payout debt disappears. The balance sheet looks cleaner and leaner, which investors and owners love. 

“Another downside … if you’re laid off, the company doesn’t have to pay out for unused vacation days. It’s a way for companies to save money.” - Reddit User 

For example, if a company owed hundreds of hours of vacation to employees, that’s money it must reserve for payouts. Move to unlimited PTO, and poof, no hours earned, no money owed. There’s no line item for earned vacation payouts under unlimited plans. 

Not only does this save the company cash in the long run, but it can also boost reported profits, since they no longer have to account for growing vacation liabilities. 

Dropping vacation accruals can remove millions in liabilities for mid-to-large companies. For employees, however, this means if you don’t take a vacation, you’ve essentially given free labor. 

Essentially, unlimited PTO often lets companies have their cake and eat it too: they get the goodwill PR of a “generous” policy, and they quietly erase a financial obligation to their workforce. 

Culture Matters More Than Policy

An unlimited PTO policy is only as good as the culture that supports it. If management doesn’t actively encourage and role-model taking time off, employees often won’t use the benefit at all. 

When leaders never unplug, responding to emails on weekends, working through vacations, they send a powerful message that productivity is valued above rest. Employees take that cue: nearly half of employees (47%) feel guilty taking time off, and almost half say they’ve read emails from their boss while on vacation.

If your manager is still online and working during their vacation, you might conclude that you’re expected to do the same. This undermines the entire point of “unlimited” PTO. People have the permission to take time, but culturally, they don’t feel they have the approval.  

A recent survey indicated that 76% of workers wish their employer placed more emphasis on the importance of taking time off. For unlimited PTO to work as intended, leadership must foster a “take the time you need” environment. That means not just saying it, but living it. It is crucial that companies back up the perk with a supportive culture; otherwise, it’s an empty gesture. 

Unfortunately, in many organizations, there’s a disconnect. The policy says “take what you want,” but the unspoken rule is “better not take too much.” Workers, especially in high-pressure teams, often feel their absence will burden colleagues or that a big deadline makes any time off taboo. 

A Better PTO Framework 

The evidence is clear: unlimited PTO often fails to deliver its promised benefits. So, what does a better framework look like? 

Crafting a PTO Policy That Actually Works 

To build a competitive and fair PTO policy that your team will actually use, create a framework built on clarity, trust, and tangible value: 

Establish a Clear Accrual System 

Treat time off as the earned compensation it is, not a vague perk. When employees earn and accumulate a set number of hours per pay period, their PTO becomes a tangible asset. This removes the anxiety and guesswork of unlimited plans because employees know exactly what they are entitled to. Crucially, it also ensures they receive a payout for unused time upon departure, rightfully compensating them for their earned benefits. 

Offer a Genuinely Generous Allotment

“Generous” shouldn’t be a buzzword, it should be a specific number that beats the industry norm. Research your field’s average PTO offerings and then exceed them. In the U.S., the average private-sector worker with a year of service gets about 11 vacation days per year, plus 7 sick days. Offering a PTO allowance that exceeds the minimum puts you clearly above average, offering employees a concrete benefit.  

The key is to provide enough time so that people can actually recharge. A truly generous PTO policy is an investment in your team’s well-being, it helps prevent burnout and signals that you genuinely value work-life balance. 

Cultivate a Supportive Work Culture

Policy alone doesn’t guarantee practice. Your company needs a pro-PTO culture. Make “yes” the default answer to time-off requests. Trust your employees to manage their responsibilities; only deny a PTO request for truly critical, unavoidable business conflicts, and communicate those clearly in advance. Managers should work with their teams to ensure coverage, rather than treating PTO as a nuisance.  

76% of employees say they wish their workplace emphasized taking time off more, emphasizing the desire for this culture shift. 

Most importantly, leadership must model the behavior. When managers and executives take their vacations (and fully disconnect while away), it sends a powerful message to everyone else: taking time off is normal and encouraged. 

Companies might even implement minimum PTO requirements. For example, some firms with unlimited PTO now mandate that employees take at least two weeks off per year to ensure they actually recharge.  

Whether you have unlimited or accrued PTO, managers should regularly remind team members to use their vacation days. The goal is a culture where taking time off is seen as healthy and normal, not a sign of slacking.

How a PTO Tracker Puts These Principles into Practice 

A well-defined policy is only effective if it’s easy to manage. This is where a dedicated leave management tool like Vacation Tracker becomes essential. It automates the administrative heavy lifting, allowing you to implement a fair, transparent, and generous accrual-based system without the manual overhead.

Here’s how it addresses the core issues of failed PTO policies: 

• Provides total clarity: Employees can check their leave balances anytime, eliminating the anxiety and ambiguity of unlimited plans. They know exactly what they’ve earned and what they can take. 
• Simplifies requests and approvals: Managers get full visibility into team schedules, making it easy to approve requests with confidence. This streamlined process supports a culture that encourages time off. 
• Automates accruals: Whether you offer a flat rate or a tiered system that rewards tenure, the tracker automates calculations, ensuring accuracy and saving valuable HR time. 
• Offers valuable insights: With detailed reports, you can monitor leave patterns, manage accrued PTO liability on your balance sheet, and ensure your policy is promoting the healthy work-life balance you intend. 

Unlimited PTO Vs Limited PTO 

Is Unlimited PTO a Red Flag? 

It can be. But it depends on how the company implements it. 

Unlimited PTO by itself isn’t inherently bad, some organizations do it well, but you need to dig deeper into the company culture before cheering for this perk. 

In some cases, leadership adopts it with good intentions but fails to ensure people actually take time off. In more cynical cases, companies introduce unlimited PTO specifically to avoid paying out unused vacation and to make themselves look good on paper, while quietly expecting employees not to take advantage.  

Research shows that companies with unlimited PTO policies had lower employee ratings for work-life balance, culture, and leadership compared to other companies, suggesting the policy sometimes coexists with poor culture. Job postings that advertise “unlimited PTO” have been found to take longer to fill on average, implying that some job seekers view it with skepticism. They worry it might be “too good to be true,”  and often they’re right. 

If you see unlimited PTO listed in a job offer, don’t assume it’s a good thing. Do your research. Look into employee reviews, read between the lines, and get a sense of how the company actually treats time off. Sites like Glassdoor can help paint a clearer picture of how happy their employees really are. 

Unlimited PTO can be a great benefit, but only in a company that genuinely supports work-life balance. But often, a generous defined PTO package at a company that actively encourages you to use it is far better than an unlimited PTO offer at a company where you’ll be chained to your desk. 

Ready to Offer a PTO Policy That Actually Works? 

Unlimited PTO may sound progressive but without structure and support, it often backfires. If you’re serious about building a time-off policy your team will actually use, it starts with visibility, consistency, and trust. 

Vacation Tracker helps you do exactly that. From automated accruals and real-time balances to transparent approval workflows, it gives you the tools to create a PTO experience that’s fair, trackable, and easy to manage, across teams, departments, and locations. 

Ditch the ambiguity. Build a better time-off culture. 

Start your free trial today and see how Vacation Tracker makes paid time off simple, transparent, and actually usable.  

Take the guesswork
out of time off tracking.

Know exactly who's off and when—no spreadsheets, no surprises.

Sign up for free

No credit card required.