What Is Seniority Vacation Scheduling?

Seniority plays an important role in the workplace. It influences where you sit, what meetings you attend, who makes decisions, and even vacations.  

It’s true! Some companies create strict policies, enabling employees to request and approve vacations based on seniority.  

Whether that sounds crazy to you, interesting, or something you’re actively doing, in this article, we’ll run through how it works and how Vacation Tracker can make this entire process so much easier. 

Defining Seniority Vacation Scheduling  

Seniority vacation scheduling is a complex process that requires a lot of planning. Companies that use this method often need to schedule their entire team’s vacations nearly a year in advance. 

Businesses will usually begin this process in November, beginning with their most senior employees and slowly making their way through their staff. Employees are expected to plan their vacations one year in advance, meaning they need to know exactly what weeks they want to take off in July, in November. This method ensures that the most senior employees get first pick when taking time off.  

There are different ways of doing this. Some employers may do it in rounds, where on the first pass, employees can only ask for one to two weeks off and then this process is repeated once those vacations are finalized. The goal here is to allow more junior employees to have a better shot at their week off.  

This method differs from the more common, first-come, first-served method, where whoever asks first gets it off. When using this method, seniority usually serves as the tiebreaker where two requests are made at the same time.  

Pros and Cons of Seniority Vacation Scheduling 

Pros

• Rewards employee loyalty: A seniority-based system recognizes and rewards long-term employees for their commitment. It provides them with tangible benefits and reinforces the idea that loyalty and tenure come with perks. 
• Simplifies decision-making for managers: No one wants to be the bad guy. Seniority Vacation Scheduling makes it easy for managers to make decisions and reduces the need for them to explain their choices. They’re just following company policy, right? 
• Can boost employee retention: If employees know that they’ll likely get the top pick on the vacation rotation, it may incentivize them to stay at the company longer, reducing turnover and increasing retention. 

Cons

• Can demotivate newer employees: While your most senior employees may feel great, being at the bottom of the totem pole is not ideal. Newer employees who constantly don’t get the week off that they anticipated might feel defeated and frustrated. 
• More admin work: It’s no secret. This method requires your HR team to be organized and proactive. It takes time to make a seniority vacation schedule work well, and if they fall behind schedule, it could cause serious issues. 
• Lots of planning: We can all agree that while most of us know we want to take time off in the summer or over the holidays, we usually don’t know exactly when until 1-2 months prior. It’s really difficult to ask employees to know the exact days they want off a year in advance, especially with some employees relying on children’s school schedules or their partner’s vacation availability. This can cause some issues internally with employees who aren’t able to predict when they want off.  

Best Practices for Implementing a Seniority Vacation Scheduling Policy

Set Clear, Written Guidelines

The first step in implementing a seniority vacation scheduling policy is to outline the process, including how seniority works in your company, how requests will be handled, and how the approval process works. Make sure your team feels informed and at ease, without any ambiguity about how everything will happen or fear that they’ll miss essential deadlines. 

Define Request Deadlines

Setting firm deadlines and restrictions is recommended to avoid scheduling conflicts or having to backtrack and redo any of your seniority vacation schedule planning. Make it absolutely clear when employees need to submit requests by and apply the policy fairly and consistently, without any exceptions. 

Establish Blackout Periods

If you have a peak season like the holidays or back to school, you may not want to allow your team to take time off during that time. Make sure your team knows when they can and can and can’t have PTO. 

Communicate, Communicate, Communicate!

Ensure all employees understand the seniority-based vacation policy by clearly communicating it in handbooks, meetings, and emails. Address concerns proactively and provide avenues for feedback. 

Leverage Vacation Tracker for Better PTO Scheduling 

While this entire system sounds quite complex, we have some good news. Using a leave management tool like Vacation Tracker can make the seniority-based scheduling process much more efficient with much less admin work.

Interested? Here’s how: 

Digital vacation requests and approvals 

Seniority vacation scheduling means your entire company needs to deliver their PTO requests to you by the same deadline. This is a nightmare scenario for any HR manager whose inbox is slowly getting flooded with requests. This is the perfect opportunity for mistakes, forgotten employees, scheduling conflicts, you name it! 

Instead of manually handling requests, employees can submit their dates digitally through Vacation Tracker. This means all the requests can be in one place, where they can’t get lost. You have a clear audit trail of their requests and as you begin approving, a message will appear if someone from the same department is already scheduled to be off during that period. Much better.

Reports for Strategic Planning

Rather than having to manually enter data or try to puzzle together your employees’ requests, while also cross-checking their start dates, employers can use Vacation Tracker to easily export requests into a neat Excel file that they can then filter by seniority or use conditional formatting to quickly highlight duplicate dates. All the information you need is now available in seconds, making your vacation scheduling so much easier.

Visibility in Team Availability

When your employees request leave only weeks before they need it, odds are you might remember that they’re away. However, when your whole team makes their PTO requests for the entire year ahead, it can be much trickier. Vacation Tracker keeps your team in the loop, so they always know who’s away and who’s scheduled to be off next.  

Seniority-Based Entitlements

While seniority vacation scheduling is a newer concept to most, seniority entitlements are quite common and sometimes even mandated by countries. For example, in Canada, employees receive 2 weeks after 1 year of employment, 3 weeks after 5 years of employment, and 4 weeks after 10 years of employment.  

Companies that value seniority enough to establish seniority vacation scheduling will likely also modify entitlements based on this.  

Vacation Tracker’s Seniority Entitlement add-on allows HR teams to track accruals according to tenure. This makes sure that employees receive the correct amount of vacation time based on company policies, simplifying the process of allocating additional leave days for long-standing employees without the need for manual calculations.

Clear Visibility of Blackout Periods

Blackout periods are important for business continuity during busy times. Vacation Tracker allows HR teams to set predefined blackout dates, preventing employees from requesting leave during critical business periods. If employees try to request leave during this period, it is automatically denied. This prevents unnecessary requests and confusion. 

Ready to take control over your vacation scheduling? 

Seniority vacation scheduling has its pros and cons, but with the right tools and strategies, companies can create a fair, efficient, and transparent system. 

And it doesn’t have to be complicated. With Vacation Tracker, businesses can automate scheduling, reduce admin workload, and improve employee satisfaction—ensuring that everyone gets their well-earned time off without the chaos. 

Try Vacation Tracker for free today and see how it can streamline your team’s leave management process.

Take the guesswork
out of time off tracking.

Know exactly who's off and when—no spreadsheets, no surprises.

Start your free trial

No credit card required.