SOURCE:    Vacation Tracker
TITLE:     Vacation Tracker vs Excel Spreadsheets | What's Best For Leave Tracking?
URL:       https://vacationtracker.io/blog/vacation-tracker-vs-excel-spreadsheets-what-s-best-for-leave-tracking/
LANG:      en
PUBLISHED: 2026-10-02
UPDATED:   2026-10-08
AUTHOR:    Nick
READING:   4 min
TAGS:      alternative, blog
SUMMARY:   Vacation Tracker vs Excel: Which Is Better for Leave Tracking? I've yet to meet a company that began PTO tracking with dedicated software.
Vacation Tracker vs Excel Spreadsheets | What's Best For Leave Tracking?

Vacation Tracker vs Excel Spreadsheets | What's Best For Leave Tracking?

Nicholas LydonContent Marketing Manager

4 min readPublished Updated

Vacation Tracker vs Excel Spreadsheets | What's Best For Leave Tracking?

Share or ask AI

Key takeaways

  • Excel works well for a small team. It's free, everybody knows it, and a handful of people can run PTO in it without trouble.
  • Vacation Tracker takes leave management to a higher level with requests, approvals, calendar updates, notifications and accruals all happen without manual typing.
  • Reporting gets easier. You can export any data or connect Vacation Tracker to your AI assistant and let it run reports.
  • Energy insights flag people running on empty. Managers can check in before burnout turns into a resignation.

Main logo
Compare

Starting Price

Main logo
Compare

Starts at $2/user/month and scales up to $4/user/month for advanced features. Includes a 14-day free trial.

depends on company plan. Individual plans start at 6.99 per month.

Free plan or free trial

Main logo
Compare

Vacation Tracker no longer supports a free plan. Free trials are free for 14 days

Microsoft 365 free trial is 1 month long.

Time to implement

Main logo
Compare

< 1 day

Depends on your spreadsheet creation ability

Advanced Leave Policies

Main logo
Compare
  • TOIL (Time Off in Lieu)
  • Seniority-based leave
  • Probation periods
  • Blackout dates
  • Accrual caps and department-level rules

Not present

Platform Integrations

Main logo
Compare
  • Slack, Microsoft Teams, Google Workspace
  • ADP and Zapier
  • Open API available
  • Mobile app

Zapier and other integrations are available

OpenAPI available

Main logo
Compare

Yes

Yes

Customer support

Main logo
Compare
  • Email support
  • Live chat
  • Guided onboarding process available on request

Private third party vendors offer classes and support is available via microsoft for general  help.

Security & Compliance

Main logo
Compare

SOC 2 Type 2 certified and GDPR compliant.

built-in protection features across the file, workbook, and worksheet levels, alongside an internal security manager called the Trust Center

Nicholas Lydon

Content Marketing Manager

Nick is the Content Marketing Manager at Vacation Tracker, where he turns leave management, HR headaches, and the occasional oddly specific PTO question into content people  can watch. He spends most of his time creating videos, articles, campaigns, and creative experiments that make HR a little less boring.

More from Nicholas

Done learning? Put it into practice.

Track PTO where your team already works: Slack, Microsoft Teams or Google Workspace. 14-day free trial. No credit card, no contract.

Rated 4.7 on Capterra and 4.4 on G2AICPA SOC 2GDPR